What about Donald Pliner Shoes:
"Tempted to buy a few more Donald Pliners just in case... Best oxford-type shoe that I have owned. The plastic sole of the shoe looks like the sole for a Dr. Marten boot, however, the look of the shoe remains excellent and the extra thickness of the sole virtually guarantees that the shoe will last a long long time. Well worth the money."

"Let me start by saying that Donald Pliners shoes are the best I have ever owned. Very well-made and stylish. I own several pairs and have been happy with them. As for the Arizonas: Originally, I had ordered the brown wax finish. This is really a funky look and almost impossible to pull off with traditional work clothing. So I switched them out for the black calf. These are very handsome shoes and really well-made. But they are POINTY. Be aware of just how pointy these babies are. People think they're cowboy boots."

"I cannot wear all Pliner shoes due to the narrowness of many, but all styles are generally very good. I wish Pliner would make a wider shoe. This one is no exception--it is a drop narrow but not uncomfortable and the shape and roominess of the toe box is excellent. This Pliner as with all others I have purchased remains beautifully made, using excellent materials , superb finish, and wonderful comfort. I am totally devoted to this great online shoe store, the best internet company I have ever dealt with overall, and 100% honorable. I buy ALL my shoes from them and will continue to do so."

Popular Donald Pliner Styles: Center, Dono, Eiver, Jador, Leo, Mario, Miles, Mincho, Monty, Pete, Rad, Rex, Terra